BBDFL

Referee and RESPECT Marking Guidance

Referee and RESPECT Marking Guidance

The mark awarded by a club must be based on the referee's overall performance. It is most important that the mark is awarded fairly and not based on isolated incidents or previous games. The referee's performance should be determined by the table below which should act as a guide for the overall mark which should fall within the mark range for each standard of performance.

 
 
 
 

Mark Range

Comment

 

91 to 100

The referee was extremely accurate in decision making and very successfully controlled the game using management and communication skills to create an environment of fair play, adding real value to the game.

 
 
 

81 to 90

The referee was very accurate in decision making and successfully controlled the game using management and communication skills to create an environment of fair play.

 
 
 

71 to 80

The referee was accurate in decision making and controlled the game well, communicating with the players, making a positive contribution towards fair play.

 
 
 

61 to 70

The referee was reasonably accurate in decision making, controlled the game quite well and communicated with players, establishing a reasonable degree of fair play.

 
 
 

51 to 60

The referee had some shortcomings in the level of accuracy of decision making and control, with only limited success in communicating with the players resulting in variable fair play.

 
 
 

50 and below

The referee had significant shortcomings in the level of accuracy of decision making and control with poor communication with the players resulting in low levels of fair play.

 
 
 

Note 1

Using a scale of up to 100 allows greater flexibility for clubs to distinguish between different refereeing performances more accurately.

 
 

Note 2

A mark within each mark range can be given to reflect the referee's performance e.g. a mark of 79 indicates a somewhat better performance than a mark of 71.

 
 
 

Note 3

A mark between 71 and 90 represents the standard of refereeing expected.

 

Note 4

When a mark of 60 or less is awarded, an explanation must be provided to the BBDFL Referees Development Officer Bill Eaton by return (see totalwanderer@googlemail.com).

It must include comments which could help improve the referee's future performances. Even where a referee has significant shortcomings there will have been some positive aspects which should be given credit. An extremely low mark (below 20) should be very rare.

NOTE: RESPECT MARKS ARE OUT OF 10: Marks of below 5 for sportsmanship, must be reported to your age group secretary by return.